The Ink-Jet Saga Continues
SDC was evaluating IJP tools from Kateeva (pvt) the leader in encapsulation IJP but chose tools made by SEMES (pvt), a Samsung affiliate, despite what we believe was data that indicated that the Kateeva product was the superior choice. While we speculated that SDC was helping to bail out SEMES, which was seeing its LCD tool business decline as SDC wound down its large panel LCD production business, at the time we could only cite 2nd hand data. SDC’s choice caused significant disruptions to Kateeva, who had produced working tools with the hope of recovering pre-order costs from SDC, and the company had to reduce its staff by over 50%, and refocus its attention on potential Chinese customers for its encapsulation IJPs.
It seems that HB Solutions (297890.KS) invested $13.5m in Kateeva earlier this year after it was thought that Samsung Display will be using Kateeva’s ink-jet printers for the potential expansion of its QD/OLED production line, after experiencing problems with the SEMES tools, with Kateeva collateralizing a number of its South Korean patents to secure the loan. HB Solutions is also said to have purchased rights to additional Kateeva patents in the US, although those might be subject to the preferential rights of another purchaser. HB Solutions would be the end supplier of the IJP tools to SDC, with Kateeva the actual source of the IJP tools.
As there have been a number of delays in the development of the QD/OLED process by SDC, with questions still remaining about how well the product is being accepted by consumers and parent Samsung Electronics’ (005930.KS) commitment to the QD/OLED product line, the pressure is on Kateeva to secure the hard orders for the equipment to maintain it ownership of its IP. As we have noted yesterday, Samsun expanded its QD/OLED marketing footprint, and while we are want to take this as a positive sign toward the QD/OLED product line, the macro environment is such that a delay in stepping up production capacity at a 2nd QD/OLED fab could push what we originally though would be an end-of-2Q decision further down the road, putting even more pressure on Kateeva. Hopefully the long-term picture for QD/OLED at Samsung Display will take precedence and a decision (including Kateeva’s IJP) will be forthcoming, but the heat is on once again at Kateeva.